Fulton and Montgomery counties have a serious classic car community. The car shows at Great Sacandaga Lake, the Route 30 corridor cruise nights, and the garages full of project vehicles that come with owning property out here — we see them regularly. And we see the insurance mistakes that go with them. The most common one: putting a restored 1967 Chevelle on a standard personal auto policy and assuming it's protected because it's technically listed.
Why standard auto insurance is the wrong policy for a classic car
Standard personal auto policies pay actual cash value (ACV) in a total loss. ACV is calculated by taking the vehicle's replacement cost and subtracting depreciation based on age, condition, and market value. For a 1965 Mustang that you've invested $25,000 in restoration, the ACV on a standard auto policy might be $12,000–$18,000 — significantly less than your real economic loss.
Collector vehicle policies work differently. The core concept is agreed value: you and the insurer agree upfront on what the vehicle is worth — supported by an appraisal, documented restoration costs, or market comps — and that number is what gets paid in a total loss, with no depreciation. A $35,000 agreed-value policy pays $35,000. No negotiation, no depreciation calculation, no argument about what condition it was in.
Hagerty: the largest collector vehicle insurer
Hagerty is the best-known name in collector vehicle insurance and for good reason — they've built their entire business around the collector car community, they understand vehicle valuations better than generalist carriers, and their claims process for total losses is well-regarded. Bashwinger writes Hagerty policies as part of our carrier market.
Hagerty policies include: agreed value coverage, spare parts coverage (typically $750–$2,000 for parts and tools in the vehicle), roadside assistance specifically designed for collector vehicles, and coverage during transport and at shows. They're designed for vehicles driven on a limited, pleasure-use basis — most policies include an annual mileage limit, typically 2,500–7,500 miles.
Hagerty alternatives available through Bashwinger
Hagerty is excellent but not the only option. Several of our standard carrier markets offer collector vehicle endorsements or specialized classic car programs that may be more cost-effective depending on the vehicle, its agreed value, and how it's used. For vehicles in the $5,000–$20,000 agreed value range, alternatives to standalone Hagerty policies are worth comparing. For multi-vehicle collector garages, umbrella coverage and bundling with home and auto can change the math significantly.
We quote both Hagerty and alternatives for every collector vehicle inquiry and show you the side-by-side comparison. The best option depends on the specific vehicle, its use profile, and how it fits into your overall insurance picture.
What makes a vehicle eligible for collector car insurance?
Most collector vehicle policies require that the vehicle be: at least 15–25 years old (varies by carrier), in good to excellent condition or a documented restoration project, not used as a primary or daily driver, stored in a secure enclosed garage, and driven a limited number of miles annually. Vehicles used for racing, timed events, or commercial purposes generally require separate specialty coverage.
Storage and transport coverage
Classic cars that spend part of the year in storage need coverage during that period too — theft, fire, and damage from falling objects can happen in a garage. Hagerty and most collector policies include full agreed-value coverage during storage. Transport coverage extends to damage incurred while the vehicle is being trailered to a show or transported by a carrier — this is not standard on all policies and worth confirming.
Classic car insurance FAQs — upstate NY
What is agreed value vs actual cash value for classic car insurance?
+
Agreed value means you and the insurer agree upfront on what the vehicle is worth — typically its appraised or documented market value — and that's what you receive in a total loss, with no depreciation applied. Actual cash value means the insurer pays what the vehicle was worth at the time of the loss, accounting for depreciation and market conditions. For a collector vehicle, agreed value is almost always the right choice — ACV on a restored classic can be significantly lower than what you've invested in the car.
Does a classic car need its own insurance policy in New York?
+
Yes, if it's a registered vehicle, it needs at least the New York State minimum liability coverage. Most personal auto policies will technically provide minimum coverage for a classic, but they'll value it as an ordinary used car. A specialized collector vehicle policy provides agreed-value coverage, protects the vehicle during storage and transport, and often includes coverage for spare parts and tools. We write both Hagerty policies and alternatives through our standard carrier markets.
Are there mileage limits on classic car insurance in NY?
+
Many collector vehicle policies include annual mileage limitations — typically 2,500–7,500 miles per year — because they're priced for occasional pleasure driving rather than daily use. If you plan to drive your classic regularly, exceed the limit, or use it for any commercial purpose (shows with entry fees, paid driver education events), you need to confirm with us that your policy accommodates that use.